Winter in New Jersey isn’t just tough on us – it’s a critical season for your koi. With temperatures in Morris County regularly dipping below freezing from December through February, your fish need specific care to survive and thrive until spring arrives. The good news? With the right preparation, your koi can handle everything a Jersey winter throws at them.

TL;DR – Quick Winter Koi Care Checklist

✅ Stop feeding when water drops below 50°F (usually late October)
✅ Keep a hole in ice with aerator or de-icer
✅ Maintain minimum 3-foot pond depth
✅ Never break ice by force – use warm water
✅ Test water quality monthly through winter
✅ Remove debris and leaves before first freeze

1. 🌡️ Know When to Stop Feeding (And Why It Matters)

Here’s something that surprises new koi owners: you’ll actually stop feeding your fish for months during winter. When water temperatures drop below 50°F – typically around late October in the Rockaway and Denville areas – your koi’s metabolism slows dramatically. They’re entering a state similar to hibernation, and their digestive systems can’t process food properly.

Feeding them during this time can lead to serious health problems, including bacterial infections and bloating. As temperatures drop into the 40s, your koi will naturally settle to the bottom of the pond where it’s slightly warmer and move very little. This is completely normal behavior.

Pro tip: Keep a pond thermometer handy and check it regularly as fall progresses. Once you hit that 50°F mark consistently, it’s time to put away the fish food until spring.

2. ❄️ Maintain Proper Ice Management

Ice formation is inevitable in New Jersey winters, but a completely frozen pond can be deadly for koi. Fish need gas exchange to survive – oxygen in, carbon dioxide and other gases out. A thick layer of ice prevents this exchange and can lead to toxic gas buildup.

Your best defense is a pond aerator or de-icer that keeps a hole in the ice throughout winter. Position your aerator near the surface (not at the bottom, which can disrupt the warmer water layers where your koi are resting). This creates enough water movement to prevent complete freeze-over even during those brutal single-digit nights we get in January.

Never break ice by hitting it or using tools. The shock waves can seriously harm or even kill your fish. If you need to create an opening, pour warm (not boiling) water on the ice to melt a hole.

3. 🏊 Depth Is Your Best Friend

In Bergen, Passaic, and Sussex counties, proper pond depth isn’t optional for koi – it’s essential for winter survival. Your pond needs to be at least 3 feet deep, but 4 feet is even better. Here’s why: as water cools, it stratifies into layers. The coldest water (32°F) stays at the top where it freezes, while the bottom water remains around 39°F – the temperature at which water is densest.

That warmer bottom layer is where your koi will spend the winter, and they need enough depth to stay in this safe zone. Shallow ponds are more likely to freeze solid or experience dangerous temperature swings that stress fish.

If you’re in the planning stages, work with an experienced pond builder who understands New Jersey’s climate requirements. Retrofitting depth later is expensive and disruptive.

4. 💨 Keep That Aerator Running

We mentioned aerators for ice management, but their importance goes beyond just keeping a hole open. Aeration is your pond’s life support system during winter. It circulates oxygen-rich water and prevents dangerous gas pockets from forming at the bottom of your pond.

Many pond owners in the Parsippany area run their aerators 24/7 from November through March. Yes, it increases your electric bill slightly, but it’s a small price compared to losing valuable koi. Modern aerators are relatively energy-efficient, and the peace of mind is worth every penny.

Position your aerator stones or diffusers about 12-18 inches below the surface during winter. Placing them too deep will disrupt the thermal layering your koi depend on.

5. 🧹 Fall Cleanup Is Winter Prep

The work you do in autumn directly impacts how well your pond – and your koi – handle winter. Decomposing leaves and organic matter consume oxygen and release harmful gases as they break down. In summer, this process is manageable. In winter under ice, it can become toxic.

Before the first hard freeze (usually mid to late November in Morris County), remove as much debris as possible. Skim leaves, trim back dead plant material, and consider using a pond net to catch falling leaves through October and November. Some pond owners even run their skimmers overtime during fall to keep up with leaf drop.

Clean your filters and remove any muck or sludge from the pond bottom. This reduces the biological load your pond needs to manage during the months when natural processes slow down.

6. 💧 Don’t Neglect Water Quality

Just because your pond looks peaceful and frozen doesn’t mean you can ignore it completely. Check on your koi at least weekly, and test water quality monthly if possible. You’re looking for dangerous ammonia or nitrite spikes, which can still occur in cold water.

If you notice your koi gasping at the surface or clustering around your aerator hole more than usual, it’s a sign of oxygen depletion or poor water quality. Don’t wait – address it immediately with increased aeration or a partial water change (using dechlorinated water at a similar temperature).

Keep snow cleared from a section of ice if possible. Sunlight penetration helps aquatic plants continue producing small amounts of oxygen and prevents excessive algae die-off that can foul water quality.

7. 🏥 Watch for Warning Signs

Even in their dormant state, koi can show signs of distress. If you see fish swimming erratically, floating near the surface for extended periods (outside the aerator hole), or displaying damaged fins or scales, something’s wrong.

Common winter problems include bacterial infections (which can still occur in cold water), parasite issues carried over from fall, and stress from poor water conditions. If you notice problems, consult with a koi health specialist or veterinarian who understands fish care. Don’t attempt to treat sick fish without professional guidance – wrong treatments in cold water can do more harm than good.

Frequently Asked Questions About Winter Koi Care in New Jersey

How deep should a koi pond be in New Jersey?
Koi ponds in New Jersey should be at least 3 feet deep, with 4 feet being ideal for winter survival. This depth ensures koi can retreat to warmer water layers that remain around 39°F even when surface water freezes. Atlantis Water Gardens builds all koi ponds in Morris County with proper winter depth requirements.

When should I stop feeding koi in Rockaway NJ?
Stop feeding your koi when water temperatures consistently drop below 50°F, typically in late October in the Rockaway area. Koi cannot digest food properly in cold water, and feeding them can cause serious health problems during winter months.

Do I need a pond heater for koi in winter?
In New Jersey, you don’t need to heat the entire pond. Instead, use a pond aerator or de-icer to maintain an opening in the ice for gas exchange. Attempting to heat a pond in Denville or Parsippany winters is expensive and unnecessary – koi are naturally adapted to survive cold temperatures.

Can koi survive a frozen pond in Morris County?
Koi can survive under ice but not in a completely frozen pond. They need unfrozen water depth (minimum 3 feet) and a hole in the ice for gas exchange. Use an aerator or de-icer to prevent complete freeze-over during harsh Bergen County winters.

What temperature is too cold for koi?
Koi can survive water temperatures just above freezing (32°F-39°F at the pond bottom). However, they become dormant and stop eating below 50°F. The real danger isn’t cold temperature but lack of oxygen and toxic gas buildup under ice in Sussex County ponds.

Should I run my pond filter in winter in New Jersey?
Many pond owners in Parsippany shut down biological filters once water drops below 45°F, as beneficial bacteria become inactive. However, continue running mechanical filtration and especially aerators through winter. Consult your pond builder about your specific system’s winter requirements.

How do I know if my koi are healthy under ice?
Healthy koi in winter should rest near the pond bottom with minimal movement. Check weekly through ice holes – look for normal coloration, intact fins, and calm behavior. Contact Atlantis Water Gardens if you notice unusual activity or signs of distress in your Morris County koi pond.

Keep Your Koi Thriving All Year Long

Winter koi care in New Jersey doesn’t have to be stressful. With proper pond depth, consistent aeration, and smart feeding schedules, your fish will emerge healthy and active when spring finally arrives. The key is preparation – taking time in fall to set up your pond for success during those long, cold months ahead.

If you’re planning a new koi pond or concerned about your current pond’s winter readiness, professional guidance makes all the difference. Properly designed ponds handle New Jersey winters with minimal intervention, letting you enjoy your water feature year-round.

Ready to build a koi pond that handles Jersey winters like a champ? Contact Atlantis Water Gardens today for expert pond design and installation throughout Morris County and beyond.

Written By: Jesse Karbowski – Atlantis Water Gardens. Serving New Jersey

Thinking that you may want to add a feature and relieve some stress? Read more about different types below:
What Winter Pond Equipment Should Be Shut Down?

How Deep for Koi to Survive Winter in New Jersey? 5 Tips