How to Make a Backyard Fish Pond
A backyard fish pond is a worthy addition to any property. It helps create a relaxinga backyard and may also increase the value of your property. A well-designed and properly constructed backyard fish pond can attract wildlife to your property, helping bring nature into your backyard.
Here is a step-by-step guide from your local koi pond contractor in Essex County to building the backyard fish pond of your dreams.
Key Takeaways
- A healthy fish pond is a balanced ecosystem: enough size and depth, good filtration, moving water, and plants all working together.
- For koi, depth matters. A pond that is too shallow struggles with temperature swings and winter survival in New Jersey.
- A small pond is a doable DIY project, but koi ponds and anything involving major digging or plumbing are usually worth a pro.
Before You Begin
For a large pond, a koi pond, or any build with real excavation and plumbing, a pro saves you from mistakes that are expensive to undo.
Common DIY Mistakes That Cost the Most
- Undersized pump
- A liner seam in the wrong spot
- A shelf cut too shallow for koi
- Poor drainage
Choosing Your Pond Location
Begin by planning the location, size, and shape of your pond. Choose a location where you can easily observe and enjoy your pond. Make sure there is no risk of falling debris such as tree branches. Avoid areas that receive direct sunlight all day or the water in your pond can overheat, which can be harmful to fish.

The size and depth of the pond will depend on the types of fish you plan to keep. For example, koi require a larger and deeper pond than goldfish. As a general rule, plan for a pond that’s at least 2 feet deep for smaller fish and up to 3-4 feet for larger ones like koi.
Where Not to Put Your Pond
Avoid placing your pond in an area where water runs off after heavy rainfall. Runoff water can infiltrate the space between the pond wall and its liner, causing the liner to rise upwards. This usually occurs if the liner wasn’t installed properly. When installing the liner, securely fasten it all around the pond’s edge, or you may have to empty the pond to mend it.
Time to Dig
Once you’ve chosen your pond’s location and design, mark the perimeter using a rope or spray paint. Start excavating within the marked boundaries. The walls should be slightly sloping rather than straight down. Leave a ledge around the edge of the pond for border decoration or plant shelves.
Ensure that the sides of the hole are level all around, as any unevenness will be visible when the pond is complete. The rim of the pond should be slightly elevated to prevent entry of rainwater runoff.
Keep Your Project Legal and Safe
In the United States, it’s a legal obligation to contact Digline at 811 before initiating any digging work. This free service will provide information about any buried utility lines, cables, pipes, or other obstacles at your intended site.
Install a Pump
A pump can help keep your pond clean and maintain optimal oxygen levels by circulating the water at least twice every hour. For ponds up to 1,500 gallons (5,678.1 L), a 1 1/2” pump is recommended. If your pond holds more than 1,500 gallons of water, opt for a 2” pump.
For a pond larger than 2,500 gallons (9,463.5 L), consider a 3” or 4” pump. Look for a PVC pump as PVC pumps are usually more affordable than flex hoses and are simpler to install. Purchase and set up the pump before laying down your pond liner.
Pond pumps come in all shapes and sizes. If you have trouble choosing the right size of pond pump, consult a fish pond installer near you in Randolph.
Install the Bottom Drain
Make sure that the bottom drain is fitted with an anti-vortex cover. Without one, the fish risk being drawn into the grating. The drain should be securely sealed through the pond liner and underlayment to ensure no leakage. If the drain fails to provide a tight seal, the whole pond could potentially fail.
Install the Pond Liner
Next, you’ll need to install a pond liner to prevent water from soaking into the ground. There are several types of liners, including PVC, EPDM, and butyl rubber. EPDM liners are quite popular due to their durability and flexibility.
To determine the size of liner you will require, follow these steps: start by dangling a string 18” from the edge of the pond where the water reaches its highest point. Let the string follow the widest part of the hole, contouring to the hole’s curves. Then, mark the string 18” away from the opposite edge. Measure the marked string. Repeat this process for the length of your pond.
Every pond liner will naturally descend and sink to the bottom of the pond as it gets filled with materials like gravel, rocks, plants, and silt. It’s crucial to procure an additional 1 foot (0.30 m), or better yet, 18-24 inches (46-61 cm) more than your initial measurements in both length and width for the liner. Should the liner retreat beneath the water’s edge, you will need to empty the pond and reinstall the liner.
Place a layer of underlayment or old carpet under the liner to protect it from sharp stones. Then lay the liner in the hole, press it into the corners, and let it follow the contours of the pond. Trim off any excess, leaving some overlap.
Install Eductor Jets and Skimmer
Eductor jets create underwater currents, pushing pond water to prevent any zones of stillness from forming. The skimmer, designed to be safe for fish, is essentially a bucket that enables the system to automatically collect fallen leaves and other debris from the water’s surface.
It’s vital to inspect the filter and filtration system at least two to three times every week to prevent any potential damage to the pump or filtration system. Regular checks will help maintain cleanliness consistently.
At this point, you will also want to install a bead filter and UV water clarifier. A bead filter captures sand and debris and also provides a habitat for beneficial bacteria, crucial for maintaining the health of a pond and the aquatic life in it. A UV clarifier works to eliminate algae blooms, helping keep pond water clean.
Adding Water and Your Fish
Add water to your pond. If you’re using tap water, treat it first to remove harmful chlorine before introducing fish. Add some aquatic plants, as they can help maintain water quality and provide cover for fish. Add fish gradually, over a few weeks. Start with hardy species as they will help establish the pond’s ecosystem.
What to Do Next
- Settle the basics. Decide on fish type (koi or goldfish), a rough size, and the best location.
- Plan the system. Match filtration, pump, and depth to the number of fish you want.
- Build and cycle it. Install the pond, run it, and let it settle before stocking.
- Add plants and fish slowly. Plant first, then add fish a few at a time so the bacteria can keep up.
Safety note: Call 811 before you dig so underground utilities get marked. It is a free service and takes only a few days to schedule.
We Can Help You Build Your Backyard Pond
Atlantis Water Gardens is a leading pond builder in Denville, NJ. Our water feature experts have years of experience transforming dull backyards into oases with stunning water features.
Reach out today to make an appointment.
Call: 973-627-0515
Frequently Asked Questions
How deep should a backyard fish pond be?
It depends on the fish. Goldfish can live in a shallower pond, while koi need more depth to handle New Jersey’s summer heat and winter cold and to overwinter safely. If you plan to keep koi, build deeper. See our koi pond depth guide for specifics.
Can I build a fish pond myself?
A small pond or container water garden is a doable DIY project. A koi pond involves excavation, liner work, plumbing, and properly sized filtration, so many homeowners bring in a certified builder to avoid costly mistakes.
How many fish can I put in my pond?
Fewer than you might think, and it is safer to understock than overstock. Too many fish produce more waste than the filter and bacteria can handle, which leads to poor water quality and algae. Pond volume and filtration set the safe number, so plan the fish load before you build.

Founder & Master Pond Builder
Jaak Harju is the founder and master pond builder of Atlantis Water Gardens, a family-owned design and build firm specializing in natural-looking ponds, waterfalls, and ecosystem water features. Since 2000, Jaak has dedicated his career to creating outdoor environments that inspire connection with nature.
With a background in landscape design and construction, Jaak brings artistry and precision to every project. He’s known nationally for his creative stonework, ecological pond design, and educational outreach within the pond-building community. Through his work, videos, and collaborations with other Aquascape-certified contractors, Jaak has helped redefine backyard water features as sustainable, living ecosystems.